Birther case against Oxy laughed out of court

obamaoxy.jpgThe student news site at Occidental College says a lawsuit by Obama conspiracy-theorist Orly Taitz provided some eye-rolling amusement in the courtroom before it was tossed out by the judge. The suit sought to force Occidental to release long-ago student Barack Obama's application and college records. Sounds like the college's general counsel, Carl Botterud, showed up in court almost for yucks, knowing that the chances of the suit not being dismissed were very, very thin. Before the hearing, he sent Taitz a note telling her of his position that the lawsuit was so frivolous that sanctions were warranted for wasting the college's time. From the Occidental Weekly:

Taitz responded forcefully and personally to Botterud in an email that was part of the court filing for the case.

“Your opposition will constitute Obstruction of Justice, Aiding and Abetting in the elections fraud in forgery and treason in allowing a foreign citizen to usurp the U.S. Presidency with an aid of forged IDs and usurp the civil rights of the U.S. citizens,” she wrote. “At any rate your opposition and your attempt of intimidation and your allegiance or lack of
allegiance to the United States of America is duly noted. Just make sure not to forget to bring with you Mr. Obama’s application, registration, and financial aid application.”

When Botterud arrived in the courtroom, he was approached by Taitz and asked if he had the President’s records with him, according to a court observer’s report. The report noted that Botterud was “obviously amused,” when he replied, “No.”

“It was a ridiculous question,” Botterud said in an interview with The Occidental Weekly.


The judge agreed with Occidental that the subpoena and motion to compel were riddled with fundamental procedural errors and denied Taitz’s motion with prejudice. According to the court observer, Judge Marginis did comment on Taitz’s quality of evidence when she presented a folder of it to the judge.

“You should know that evidence is not stuff printed from the internet,” Marginis said, responding to Taitz’s continued argument after he made the decision to quash the subpoena and award $4,000 in sanctions to Occidental College.

More by Kevin Roderick:
DA drops murder case against tennis umpire
Birther case against Oxy laughed out of court
Morning Buzz: Friday 11.30.12
Madeleine Brand's talks with KCRW seem to be progressing
Andrea Alarcon at a hotel when her daughter found in City Hall
Recent Colleges stories on LA Observed:
Birther case against Oxy laughed out of court
Bruins start their Pac-12 Championship Series
UCLA 38, USC 28
Overholser to leave USC-Annenberg next year
USC library repurposes card catalog drawers

New at LA Observed
Follow us on Twitter

On the Media Page
Go to Media
On the Politics Page
Go to Politics

LA Biz Observed
Arts and culture

Sign up for daily email from LA Observed

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

LA Observed on Twitter and Facebook