Something funny about this mag list


In his column at TV Week, Alex Ben Block rips Entertainment Weekly's ranking of the "25.5 funniest people in America." In fact, he calls it "one of the worst power lists ever published by a major magazine." On the list: Augusten Burroughs, Scot Armstrong, Demetri Martin and Kelly Ripa. Not mentioned are any of Robin Williams, Steve Martin, Billy Crystal, Ray Romano, Jimmy Kimmel, Jay Leno or Jerry Seinfeld.

Being the editor of a magazine, Block phoned up EW and got writer Josh Wolk on the line.

"You should see the people screaming about this," Mr. Wolk chuckled. "We're getting tons of mail. This is one of those topics everybody has really strong opinions about."

It may say on the cover next to a picture of No. 1 pick Chris Rock that the list is of the 25 funniest people in America, but there should be a footnote that tells the truth: This is the list of the funniest people who are not excessively popular or, god forbid, mainstream...

Of course, humor is not easy to quantify. But that is not a license to be stupid. If this were a list by some blogger sitting in his bedroom dazed by too much TV, too many Twinkies and an overload of DVD extras, it would be one thing. However, this is a mainstream magazine that purports to know who is hot and who is not.

More by Kevin Roderick:
Standing up to Harvey Weinstein
The Media
LA Times gets a top editor with nothing but questions
LA Observed Notes: Harvey Weinstein stripped bare
LA Observed Notes: Photos of the homeless, photos that found homes
Recent Magazines stories on LA Observed:
Mary Melton exits as Los Angeles Magazine sold
Media notes: Nikki Finke going to Harvard, local Ellies and more
Janice Min leaving THR, Matthew Belloni upped
Read the LA Times response to Los Angeles Magazine's piece
LA Magazine says editor Davan Maharaj is what's wrong with the LA Times*
Brian Lowry to CNN and more media notes
How TMZ and Harvey Levin get the dirt
LA's breast fixation and more greatest hits from Los Angeles Mag


LA Observed on Twitter