Immigration

Villaraigosa: Heartened to a point by ruling on SB 1070

av-obama-lax.jpgMayor Antonio Villaraigosa, who's emerging as a major public face on immigration and Latino affairs for President Obama's reelection campaign, calls today's Supreme Court decision on the Arizona law that targets illegal immigrants "only a partial victory."

Here's his statement:

I am heartened by today’s Supreme Court decision to strike down key elements of Arizona’s controversial SB 1070. The Supreme Court rightly upheld the bedrock constitutional principle that the federal government alone has the power to regulate immigration. It is clear that the Obama Administration and the Department of Justice were right to challenge this law.


But today’s ruling must be seen as only a partial victory. The Supreme Court’s decision does allow Arizona to implement the law’s most problematic and potentially most harmful section: the ‘papers please’ provision.

By requiring police officers to demand documents of anyone they suspect of being in the country without authorization, Arizona risks creating a culture of fear and suspicion. Implementation of the law will undermine the trust between the police and the public, driving a wedge between police officers and the community they serve. The papers please provision opens the door for racial profiling, and I believe it will be impossible to implement this law without discrimination. This will just invite further litigation.

In today’s decision, the Supreme Court rightly drew attention to the lasting contributions that immigrants have made to this country. We need a sensible and humane national immigration policy. We do not need a confusing patchwork of 50 state laws. It is time for Congress to act. It is time to pass the DREAM ACT and it is time to enact comprehensive immigration reform. We need a national solution to this national challenge.


More by Kevin Roderick:
Standing up to Harvey Weinstein
The Media
LA Times gets a top editor with nothing but questions
LA Observed Notes: Harvey Weinstein stripped bare
LA Observed Notes: Photos of the homeless, photos that found homes
Recent Immigration stories on LA Observed:
Hahn vs. the sheriff on immigration
Cardinal Mahony still walks the walk on refugees and migrants
Weekend chaos at LAX over Trump bans
Helping hand for immigrants
LA Times says pro-internment letters should not have run
Jose Antonio Vargas and the LA Times agree to break up
Lalo Alcaraz on how to make it in Hollywood*
How immigration in U.S. has shifted through times


 

LA Observed on Twitter