That Bush-Kerry spoof *

The creators of that cartoon parody sweeping through the Web — a Shockwave clip of Bush and Kerry singing to the tune of "This Land is Your Land" — are based in Santa Monica. And now they might get sued. Gregg and Evan Spiridellis of JibJab Media have gotten a demand from the current rights holder to stop "damaging" the Woody Guthrie song. Boing Boing points out, however, that Guthrie's standard copyright notice was quite forgiving:

"This song is Copyrighted in U.S., under Seal of Copyright # 154085, for a period of 28 years, and anybody caught singin it without our permission, will be mighty good friends of ourn, cause we don't give a dern. Publish it. Write it. Sing it. Swing to it. Yodel it. We wrote it, that's all we wanted to do."

JibJab's lawyer adds that the brothers aren't hurting the song, they are engaging in protected political satire. (And, he might add, making the tune familiar to a new generation of potential listeners). That, let's hope, is the end of that. More at LAVoice.org. Richard Rushfield, meanwhile, is bored with the whole thing already.

* July 30 update: The legal nuances of "satire" vs. "parody" and how that could be bad news for JibJab, explored by Reason managing editor Jesse Walker.

9:48 AM Tuesday, July 27 2004 • Link
More by tag: Websites
Email or share:

JibJab isn't the first to parody "This Land is My Land." Dave Barry wrote an American History book several years ago, and if I recall correctly, he included the following in the book:

"This land is your land
This land is my land
Looks like one of us
Has a forged deed to this land"

Posted by: Ontario Emperor at July 27, 2004 11:01 AM

Good God. The really scary part is that if these scumbag lawyers (but I repeat myself) go through with their threat, they might actually win. The Ninth Circuit takes a very narrow view of the parody defense, protecting only parodies that actually make fun of the work parodied, rather than making fun of something else (e.g., Bush and Kerry). Remember "The Cat Not in the Hat," the O.J. parody? Dr. Seuss's estate sued, and won.

Dave Barry's parody, by contrast, is aimed at the work itself, and would presumably be protected even here in Hollyweird Circuit.

Posted by: Xrlq at July 27, 2004 12:58 PM

Personally I think that people are using the court system for too many petty things. I think that if the makers of this parody are sued then anyone who wants to make fun of something will be open to frivolous lawsuits. These people are simply making a political satire their not trying to defame the song.

Posted by: Jacqueline Sharp at August 2, 2004 07:33 AM
Comment posting has been turned off









Remember personal info?






© 2003-2008   •  About LA Observed  •  Contact the editor
LA Biz Observed
12:57 PM Wed | So much for the hope that the market had hit bottom earlier in the week.
12:00 PM Wed | Given the accuracy of 2008's economic forecasts you might wonder whether it's worth the effort.
Featured bloggers at LA Observed
Bill Boyarsky
Some USC journalism professors are raising questions about a proposal for the Annenberg School for Communication to sign a $3 million contract to help American University in Dubai create a journalism and communication school.
TJ Sullivan | Even if we rounded a bunch of them up, verified their undecidedness, and tied them down to watch tonight's debate, of what meaningful use would their opinions be?
Sara Catania | A few questions for Barack Obama and John McCain
Denise Hamilton | It was 59 years ago today that brunette starlet Jean Spangler vanished, leaving behind a young daughter, gangster pals, movie...
Here in Malibu
I love this tree, big and pink, just standing there. It's in an empty spot that has been the site...
Phil Wallace | After 22 years of loyalty, Baylor is unceremoniously shown the door.
Sponsors
Jewish Journal logo
California Wellness Foundation
Playa Vista ad
Premium Blogads

 
Books, Blogs & Events

Get RSS Feeds
of LA Observed
LA Observed publishes several Real Simple Syndication feeds for easy scanning of headlines. If you wish to subscribe to a feed, most popular RSS readers will do it for you. You can also enter the web address from the XML button below or click on a specific feed. For more help with RSS, try here or here.




Add to Google