CJR to Tribune: get out

An unsigned editorial in the Columbia Journalism Review calls on Chicago's Tribune company not just to sell off the Los Angeles Times, but to quit the newspaper business entirely. After more than a century in the business, CJR says, Tribune has reached a Rumsfeld moment. Time to take a chance on the billionaires:

Tribune has had tough luck. It paid dearly ó $8.3 billion ó for Times Mirror and then the dot-com bubble promptly burst and sank the stock market; Newsday contributed a circulation scandal; the IRS ruled against the company in a $1 billion dispute; and the courts sent the FCCís plan to relax cross-ownership rules ó which Tribune had counted on ó back to the drawing board.

But to paraphrase Donald Rumsfeld, you fight the war youíve got. Between its eleven dailies ó including the Hartford Courant, the Baltimore Sun, The South Florida Sun-Sentinel, the Orlando Sentinel, Newsday, and the Los Angles Times ó and its twenty-four TV stations, Tribune claims to reach 80 percent of U.S. households. The idea was to use that size to the companyís advantage. First, Tribune would use its TV-print overlaps to create editorial and advertising synergies; second, it would sell national advertising based on its big footprints in New York, Chicago, and L.A.; third, the merger would create efficiencies and the company could cut costs. But Tribuneís effort at merging the two cultures was ham-handed at best. And national advertisers, it turned out, didnít see how those three markets made sense as a buy. The only thing left was the easy part ó cutting costs.

Good editors will cut costs when it is part of a sensible business plan. But in time Tribune appeared to be simply harvesting the assets of its properties. Newsday and others were picked nearly clean and Tribune began turning to L.A. again this fall. To Jeffrey Johnson and Dean Baquet, the former publisher and former editor of the Los Angeles Times, Tribune must have sounded like the motorcycle thugs in Hunter Thompsonís first book, Hellís Angels. In Thompsonís telling, the Angels come up to you in a bar and say, Give me a cigarette. Then: Give me another cigarette. Then: Give me the pack. Give me your shirt. At some point you realize you might as well fight....

Public ownership of newspapers no longer makes the kind of sense it made when the industry was rapidly shedding labor costs thanks to new technology, and when the money that stockholders poured in was invested partly in editorial. Today newspapers need owners with the patience and the guts to ride through this valley of transition, with its attendant economic uncertainty, and find the next high ground, which will probably have something to do with the Internet....

Tribune has great resources, but those resources arenít doing much public good. The company seems less than the sum of its parts. And so, like Rumsfeld, it should go. Weíll take our chances with the gaggle of billionaires who are lining up to buy those newspapers. Some of them may turn out to be pirates (see Santa Barbara). But others will be citizens who understand that those dailies are not mere pieces of an economic puzzle but great living institutions rooted in the lives of their cities.

Former Tribune staffer Gary Dretzka, now a columnist at Movie City News, adds a comment at Romenesko. He wrote about Tribune here at LA Observed last month.


More by Kevin Roderick:
Ralph Lawler of the Clippers and the age of Aquarius
Riding the Expo Line to USC 'just magical'
Last bastion of free parking? Loyola Marymount to charge students
Matt Kemp, Dodgers and Kings start big weekend the right way
LA Times writers revisit their '92 riots observations
Recent LAT stories on LA Observed:
LA Times writers revisit their '92 riots observations
Los Angeles more worldly since '92, LA Times 'more insular'
More recommended media coverage of the riots
Fiction does have a winner at LA Times Book Prizes
LA Times geography throws USC a curve

New at LA Observed
Follow us on Twitter

On the Media Page
Go to Media
On the Politics Page
Go to Politics

LA Biz Observed
Arts and culture

Sign up for daily email from LA Observed

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner


Advertisement
LA Observed on Twitter and Facebook